Higgins Lake Fishing Guide: Best Spots, Tips and What to Catch
Higgins Lake is one of Michigan’s premier inland fishing destinations. Known for its extraordinary water clarity and cold, deep waters, the lake supports a healthy mix of fish species that attract anglers from across the state year-round. Whether you’re a seasoned fisherman or a first-time visitor with a rental rod, this guide covers everything you need to know about fishing Higgins Lake.
What Fish Are in Higgins Lake?
Higgins Lake supports a diverse fishery. The most sought-after species include:
Lake Trout — The crown jewel of Higgins Lake fishing. The lake is one of the few inland lakes in Michigan with a naturally reproducing lake trout population, supplemented by regular stocking from the Michigan DNR. Lake trout prefer the deep, cold water and are typically targeted by trolling or deep jigging.
Smallmouth Bass — Higgins Lake has a strong smallmouth bass population. They congregate around rocky points, submerged structure, and the transitions between sandy flats and deeper water. Smallmouth are aggressive fighters and one of the most fun species to target on light tackle.
Yellow Perch — Perch are abundant and make excellent table fare. They’re typically found in schools over sandy flats in 15–30 feet of water. Light jigs tipped with wax worms or small minnows are the go-to presentation.
Cisco (Lake Herring) — Cisco are a cold-water species present in Higgins Lake and are particularly popular targets during ice fishing season. They’re also an important forage fish that supports the lake trout population.
Bluegill and Sunfish — Found near the shallower areas and docks, these are great for kids and casual anglers.
Best Fishing Spots on Higgins Lake
The lake’s clear water means fish can see structure and cover clearly — which also means they can see you. Stealth matters more here than on murkier lakes.
Deep Water Trout Zone — Lake trout spend most of their time in the deeper central basin of the lake, typically 60–100+ feet down during summer. Trolling with spoons or deep-diving crankbaits is the most effective approach.
Rocky Points and Transitions — Smallmouth bass stack up along rocky structure, particularly on the north and east sides of the lake where the bottom transitions from sand to rock.
Sandy Flats — Yellow perch roam the sandy mid-depth flats. Drift fishing or anchoring over 20–25 feet of water and dropping small jigs is consistently productive.
Near Shore Structure — Docks, fallen timber, and weed edges hold bluegill and the occasional largemouth bass.
Ice Fishing on Higgins Lake
Ice fishing is extremely popular on Higgins Lake and draws a large crowd each winter. Cisco fishing through the ice is a unique and exciting experience — cisco school up in large numbers under the ice in winter and can be caught in rapid succession when you find them.
Lake trout are also targeted through the ice, requiring heavier gear and larger presentations. Yellow perch ice fishing is consistently productive and a great option for families.
The ice fishing season typically runs from January through early March, depending on ice conditions. Always check ice thickness before venturing out — 4 inches is the minimum for foot travel, 8–12 inches for snowmobiles.
Fishing Regulations
Higgins Lake falls under Michigan DNR fishing regulations. A valid Michigan fishing license is required for anyone 17 and older. Lake trout have specific size and bag limits that change periodically — always check the current Michigan DNR Fishing Guide before your trip for the most up-to-date rules.
Tips for Fishing Higgins Lake
- The water is exceptionally clear, so use lighter line and more natural presentations than you might on other lakes
- Early morning and evening are the most productive times for most species
- Wind-blown points concentrate baitfish and attract predators
- A fish finder is especially helpful given the lake’s depth and the need to locate fish vertically
- A UPF 50+ sun hat is essential — you’ll be exposed on open water for hours
Launching and Access
Public boat launches are available at both North and South Higgins Lake State Parks. A Michigan DNR Recreation Passport is required for launch access. The launches are well-maintained and can accommodate trailered boats.
If you’re staying at a lakefront or near-lake rental like Winter-Chard Lake Forest Chalet, you may have easier private access for kayak or canoe fishing without the boat launch crowds.
Final Thoughts
Higgins Lake rewards patient, thoughtful anglers. The water clarity that makes it so beautiful also makes it more challenging — but when you pull a lake trout out of 80 feet of crystal-clear water or land a hard-fighting smallmouth off a rocky point, it’s worth every bit of effort. Add Higgins Lake to your Michigan fishing list and give yourself at least a full day on the water.